Recommended Restaurants
Jakes Restaurant
Seafood, Jamaican
Jakes Hotel, Treasure Beach, Jamaica
Must Try: Grilled seafood, salads, Jamaican classics: conch fritters, coconut curried chicken, callaloo. Daily changing menu featuring vegetables grown locally.
Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Local Tips
Visit during the late afternoon around 4-5 PM when the restaurant is less crowded and you can enjoy the beautiful sunset views from their oceanfront terrace without competing for the best tables.
Ask your server about the catch of the day prepared Jamaican style - it's often fresher and better priced than the regular menu fish options, and the chef will prepare it with local seasonings that aren't listed on the tourist menu.
Avg. per person
$30
$$
Jack Sprat
Seafood, Pizza
Jakes Hotel, Treasure Beach, Jamaica
Must Try: Treasure Beach hotspot for fresh grilled seafood and wood-fired pizza (pepperoni, lobster, jerk chicken). Ice cream counter and regular beach bonfires.
Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Local Tips
Visit Jack Sprat during weekday lunches (Tuesday-Thursday, 12-2pm) when it's much quieter and you'll get more personalized service from the staff, plus better chances of snagging their coveted beachfront tables without a reservation.
Ask for the 'local portion' of their fish dishes - it's not on the tourist menu but locals know you can request a smaller portion at about 60% of the regular price, which is still plenty of food and comes with the same sides.
Avg. per person
$30
$$
Floyd's Pelican Bar
Seafood, Jamaican
Parottee Bay, St. Elizabeth Parish, Jamaica
Must Try: Coolest bar in the world - rustic beach bar sits in middle of the sea. Boat ride required. Fresh lobster, fish, shrimp while listening to reggae. Unforgettable experience.
Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Local Tips
Visit Floyd's Pelican Bar on weekdays before 2 PM to avoid the cruise ship crowds and have a more authentic experience with locals. The bar gets packed with tour groups in the late afternoon, especially when ships dock in Montego Bay.
Bring cash in small bills (US dollars or Jamaican dollars) as the bar operates on a cash-only basis and doesn't always have change for large bills. Also, tip your boat captain well - they often know the best spots for swimming and can take you to less crowded areas around the bar.
Avg. per person
$30
$$
Little Ochie Seafood Restaurant
Seafood, Jamaican
Alligator Pond, Manchester Parish, Jamaica
Must Try: Must-visit for authentic Jamaican seafood. Local favorite known for freshest catch and traditional preparation. South Coast gem.
Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Local Tips
Visit Little Ochie on weekday afternoons between 2-4 PM to avoid the cruise ship crowds that typically arrive around lunchtime and early evening. You'll get better service, fresher catches, and can actually enjoy the waterfront atmosphere without fighting for space.
Ask for the catch of the day to be prepared 'escovitch style' even if it's not on the menu - the kitchen will gladly do it and it's how locals prefer their fish. Also, request extra festival (fried dumplings) which pairs perfectly with their pepper shrimp but tourists often miss this classic combination.
Avg. per person
$30
$$
Gizmos & Gadgets
International, Pizza
Treasure Beach, Jamaica
Must Try: Laid-back beachside eatery with wood-fired pizza, gourmet burgers, and tropical cocktails. Popular with locals and tourists.
Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Local Tips
Visit during weekday lunch hours (11am-2pm) when the local office workers come in - you'll get fresher food and faster service compared to peak dinner hours when it gets crowded with tourists from nearby resorts.
Ask about their daily lunch specials that aren't always posted on the main menu - locals know to inquire about rice and peas with curry chicken or stew peas combos that cost significantly less than the tourist-oriented dinner plates.
Avg. per person
$30
$$
No restaurants match your filters. Try adjusting your selection.