‹ Back to Caribbean

Compass Cay, Exuma

UPSCALE November-April NAS - Nassau Lynden Pindling International Airport Bahamian Dollar (BSD)

Trip Profile

Budget Category UPSCALE $400-600 per person

Perfect For

Adventure Luxury Romantic Outdoors Family Beach

Traveler Scores

Family-Friendly

7.0/10

Romance

9.0/10

Adventure

8.0/10

Relaxation

9.0/10

Travel Planning

Current Weather at Airport

Loading weather...

Best Months to Visit

November-April

Hurricane Season

June-November

Peak: December-March | Shoulder: April-May, November

Airport

NAS - Nassau Lynden Pindling International Airport

Passport Required | No Visa Required

Bahamian Dollar (BSD)

English

Explore Other Destinations

More places we help travelers plan

Ocho Rios, Jamaica

Jamaica's adventure tourism capital, home to Dunn's River Falls. Features Sandals Ochi, Sandals Dunn's River, RIU…

Explore Ocho Rios

St. Lucia

#1 ranked Caribbean destination for 2026 (U.S. News). Most romantic Caribbean island featuring iconic Pitons UNESCO…

Explore St. Lucia

Grand Cayman, Cayman Islands

Seven Mile Beach and Stingray City. Features Ritz-Carlton, Kimpton Seafire, Marriott, and Westin. Luxury destination…

Explore Grand Cayman

Exuma, Bahamas

Famous for swimming pigs at Big Major Cay. Features Grand Isle Resort and upcoming Rosewood Exuma (opening 2028).…

Explore Exuma

Tortola, British Virgin Islands

#2 ranked Caribbean destination for 2026 (U.S. News). Sailing paradise with over 60 islands to explore. Features…

Explore Tortola

Mazatlán, Mexico

Explore Mazatlán with a local travel specialist.

Explore Mazatlán

Punta Cana, Dominican Republic

#1 most visited Caribbean destination with 50,000+ hotel rooms. Home to the highest concentration of all-inclusive…

Explore Punta Cana

Montego Bay, Jamaica

Jamaica's tourism capital with Sangster International Airport providing easiest access. Home to 7 Sandals properties…

Explore Montego Bay

Swipe to explore more destinations →

When to visit Compass Cay

Best months

November-April

Peak season

December-March

Shoulder season

April-May, November

Off season

June-October

Hurricane season

June-November

Compass Cay quick facts

Main airport

NAS - Nassau Lynden Pindling International Airport

Language

English

Currency

Bahamian Dollar (BSD)

Typical daily cost

$400-600 per person

Budget category

Upscale

Getting around Compass Cay

Transportation is exclusively by boat or seaplane, as Compass Cay has no roads or infrastructure. Most visitors join organized boat tours or charter private vessels from Nassau or nearby Exuma resorts.

Rental car

Rental cars are completely unnecessary and impossible to use on Compass Cay, as it's a small uninhabited island accessible only by water.

Rideshare & taxis

No rideshare services exist on or to Compass Cay. All transportation is water-based through tour operators or private boat charters.

Local tips for Compass Cay

Insider tips

Visit early in the morning when sharks are most active and waters are calmest.
Book tours through reputable operators who follow wildlife protection guidelines.
Bring an underwater camera or GoPro as the shark encounters make incredible photos.
Wear reef-safe sunscreen to protect the marine environment.
Combine your visit with stops at nearby Staniel Cay and Big Major Cay for a full Exuma experience.
Check weather conditions before booking as rough seas can cancel trips.
Respect the sharks by not touching or cornering them during your swim.
Consider staying at Staniel Cay Yacht Club for easier access to Compass Cay.
Pack light snacks and plenty of water as there are no facilities on the island.
Tip your boat captain and guide generously as they ensure your safety and experience quality.

What to pack

Snorkeling gear and mask
Waterproof camera or GoPro
Reef-safe sunscreen SPF 50+
Quick-dry swimwear
Water shoes for rocky areas
Lightweight cover-up
Waterproof phone case
Wide-brimmed sun hat
Insulated water bottle
Dry bag for valuables

Sample itinerary: 3 days in Compass Cay

A suggested day-by-day plan your travel agent can customize.

Day 1: Exuma Cays Discovery

Morning: Depart Nassau on a full-day boat tour to the Exuma Cays. Make your first stop at Staniel Cay to see the famous swimming pigs at Big Major Cay.

Afternoon: Arrive at Compass Cay for your shark swimming experience with nurse sharks in the shallow lagoon. Enjoy snorkeling and exploring the pristine beaches.

Evening: Return to Nassau with stops at additional cays along the way. Enjoy dinner at a waterfront restaurant celebrating your unique wildlife encounters.

Day 2: Private Island Experience

Morning: Charter a private boat or seaplane for a more intimate Compass Cay experience. Enjoy having the shark lagoon mostly to yourself in the early hours.

Afternoon: Explore the entire island, snorkel in different areas, and relax on secluded beaches. Have a picnic lunch on the pristine white sand.

Evening: Watch the sunset from the water before heading back to your Nassau hotel or nearby Exuma resort for a romantic dinner.

Day 3: Extended Exuma Adventure

Morning: Join a multi-stop Exuma tour visiting Compass Cay, Iguana Beach, and Thunderball Grotto for snorkeling. Experience the diverse wildlife of the region.

Afternoon: Visit local Exuma communities and enjoy authentic Bahamian cuisine at a waterfront restaurant on Staniel Cay or nearby settlements.

Evening: Return to Nassau or your Exuma accommodation, stopping for final photos and memories of the crystal-clear waters and marine life.

Chat with Courtney to plan your dream Compass Cay itinerary

A day-by-day plan built around your dates, pace, and budget, by a real advisor who prices Compass Cay trips every week. Free, because resorts pay her, not you.

Plan my dream itinerary

Free consultation · No obligation · Replies within 24 hours

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about visiting Compass Cay

The best time to visit Compass Cay is November-April. Peak season runs December-March, offering the best weather but higher prices and larger crowds. Shoulder season (April-May, November) provides a great balance of good weather and lower prices. Note that hurricane season is June-November.

A typical daily cost in Compass Cay is $400-600 per person per person. Compass Cay is generally considered a upscale destination.

Yes, US citizens need a valid passport to visit Compass Cay. No visa is required for US citizens for short stays.

The main airport serving Compass Cay is NAS - Nassau Lynden Pindling International Airport. The primary language spoken is English. The currency used is Bahamian Dollar (BSD).

Essential items to pack for Compass Cay include: Snorkeling gear and mask, Waterproof camera or GoPro, Reef-safe sunscreen SPF 50+, Quick-dry swimwear, Water shoes for rocky areas, Lightweight cover-up, Waterproof phone case, Wide-brimmed sun hat. Always check the weather forecast before your trip and pack layers for varying conditions.

Here are some insider tips for Compass Cay: Visit early in the morning when sharks are most active and waters are calmest.. Book tours through reputable operators who follow wildlife protection guidelines.. Bring an underwater camera or GoPro as the shark encounters make incredible photos.. Wear reef-safe sunscreen to protect the marine environment.. Combine your visit with stops at nearby Staniel Cay and Big Major Cay for a full Exuma experience..