Maui vs the Big Island: Which Hawaiian Island Wins?
Which destination is right for your next trip? Here's a side-by-side breakdown.
Maui is the polished, do-it-all island with the best beaches and resorts; the Big Island is more raw and varied, active volcanoes, black sand, stargazing, and usually a bit cheaper. First-timers lean Maui; repeat visitors wanting something different lean Big Island.
Overview
Ratings
Daily Costs
Who should choose which
Choose Maui for the Road to Hana, Haleakala sunrise, top beaches, and the most refined resort scene.
Choose the Big Island for active volcanoes, Mauna Kea stargazing, diverse landscapes, and better value.
Maui is the crowd-pleaser and the classic first-timer's Hawaii: world-class beaches, the Road to Hana, the Haleakala sunrise, whale watching in winter, and Wailea and Kaanapali's polished resorts. It does everything well and is the easiest island to fall for.
The Big Island is Hawaii turned up to extremes, you can see active lava at Volcanoes National Park, stand on black-and-even-green-sand beaches, and stargaze from Mauna Kea, all within a day's drive. It is more spread out and its beaches are fewer, but it is more varied, more adventurous, and generally cheaper. Choose Maui for the complete polished trip, the Big Island to see the Hawaii most visitors miss.
Frequently asked questions
Is Maui or the Big Island better for a first trip to Hawaii?
Which island is cheaper?
Still can't decide?
Courtney has planned trips to both and can match the right one to your dates, budget, and who's traveling. Free, no obligation.
Ask Courtney