Barbados or St. Lucia — How to Choose the Right Island for Your Trip
Which destination is right for your next trip? Here's a side-by-side breakdown.
St. Lucia is the dramatic, romantic pick with the Piton mountains and lush scenery; Barbados is the polished, sociable island with better beaches, dining, and nightlife. Honeymooners lean St. Lucia; variety-seekers lean Barbados.
Overview
Ratings
Daily Costs
Who should choose which
Choose Barbados for calm west-coast beaches, a great restaurant and rum scene, and easy exploring.
Choose St. Lucia for Piton-view resorts, rainforest adventure, and the Caribbean's most romantic scenery.
St. Lucia sells drama. The twin Pitons rising from the sea give it the most cinematic backdrop in the Caribbean, and the Soufriere resorts are built for honeymoons, open-wall suites, plunge pools, volcano mud baths. The beaches are volcanic and smaller; you are paying for the view and the lush interior, not the sand.
Barbados is more of an all-rounder. The west coast's Platinum beaches are calm and swimmable, the food-and-rum culture is the best of any island its size (Friday night at Oistins is a rite of passage), and it is easy to get around. It feels polished and British-Caribbean. Choose St. Lucia for romance and scenery, Barbados for beaches, dining, and a livelier week.
Frequently asked questions
Which is more romantic, Barbados or St. Lucia?
Which has better beaches?
Still can't decide?
Courtney has planned trips to both and can match the right one to your dates, budget, and who's traveling. Free, no obligation.
Ask Courtney